Anabelle Colaco
06 Sep 2025, 19:53 GMT+10
SAN FRANCISCO, California: A U.S. judge has ordered Google to change how its search engine operates, curbing tactics he deemed monopolistic but stopping short of the harshest penalties sought by regulators, including dismantling its Chrome browser or banning lucrative default search deals.
In a 226-page ruling, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta laid out remedies meant to rein in Google's dominance while acknowledging that rapid advances in artificial intelligence are already reshaping how people search for information. The decision follows a nearly five-year Justice Department antitrust case that began under Donald Trump and was carried forward by Joe Biden's administration.
"Unlike the typical case where the court's job is to resolve a dispute based on historic facts, here the court is asked to gaze into a crystal ball and look to the future. Not exactly a judge's forte," Mehta wrote.
The order bars Google from signing exclusive contracts that position its search engine, Gemini AI app, Play Store, or virtual assistant as the only option on devices. Google must also share parts of its search data — information gathered from trillions of user queries — with rivals to level the playing field.
Still, the ruling left untouched Google's multi-billion-dollar agreements that make it the default search engine on smartphones and browsers, including Apple's Safari. Mehta said ending those deals could backfire, depriving companies of key revenue while doing little to change consumer behavior. Apple alone receives more than US$20 billion a year from Google for its default status.
Mehta also declined the Justice Department's push to force a divestiture of Chrome, calling it "incredibly messy and highly risky." Tech rivals, including Perplexity and OpenAI, had already signaled interest in buying the browser, with Perplexity even making an unsolicited $34.5 billion offer last month.
The decision drew mixed reactions. Antitrust chief Gail Slater called it "a major win for the American people" but said the DOJ was weighing whether the relief goes far enough. Google portrayed the ruling as validation of its defense that the industry has changed dramatically with AI: "Competition is intense and people can easily choose the services they want," said Lee-Anne Mulholland, vice president of regulatory affairs.
Critics, however, said Mehta had gone too easy. "You don't find someone guilty of robbing a bank and then sentence him to writing a thank you note for the loot," argued Nidhi Hegde of the American Economic Liberties Project.
Investors appeared to agree with Google's take. Shares of parent company Alphabet surged more than seven percent in after-hours trading, adding nearly $200 billion in market value. Apple's stock also climbed three percent.
The ruling does not end Google's legal troubles. Another antitrust trial targeting its advertising business is set to begin later this month in Virginia, raising the prospect of further battles over the company's power.
Get a daily dose of Dallas Sun news through our daily email, its complimentary and keeps you fully up to date with world and business news as well.
Publish news of your business, community or sports group, personnel appointments, major event and more by submitting a news release to Dallas Sun.
More InformationCAPE CANAVERAL, Florida: Skywatchers are in for a cosmic treat this weekend as the year's second total lunar eclipse makes its appearance...
LISBON, Portugal: Fifteen people were killed and 18 others, including a child, suffered injuries when one of Lisbon's most famous tourist...
BRASILIA, Brazil: Former Brazilian President Jair Bolsonaro is fighting a high-stakes legal battle that could decide his future. His...
WASHINGTON, D.C.: U.S. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. is facing intensifying pressure to resign after more than 20 leading...
BOSTON, Massachusetts: A federal judge has handed Harvard University a significant victory in its escalating clash with the Trump administration,...
LAHORE, Pakistan: India has issued a second warning to Pakistan within two weeks about the risk of cross-border flooding as relentless...
PARIS, France: France's data watchdog has slapped fast-fashion giant Shein with a hefty 150 million-euro (US$176 million) penalty,...
NEW DELHI, India: India is moving to shore up domestic demand and soften the blow from steep new U.S. tariffs by cutting taxes on hundreds...
TOKYO, Japan: Takeshi Niinami, chief executive of Japanese beverage giant Suntory, has resigned amid a police investigation into his...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: Chinese suppliers that once fueled America's gray market for cut-price weight-loss drugs are pivoting toward...
SAN FRANCISCO, California: A U.S. judge has ordered Google to change how its search engine operates, curbing tactics he deemed monopolistic...
NEW YORK CITY, New York: Amazon Prime members will soon lose the ability to extend their free shipping perks to friends or relatives...